motion to recuse judge new york

Amended (C)(3)(b)(ii). All Rights Reserved. [NY Jud. This paragraph does not apply to proceedings in which the judge is a litigant in a personal capacity. A judge absolutely may not preside over cases where (1) the judge has a personal bias or prejudice concerning a party; (2) the judge served as a lawyer in the matter in controversy; (3) the judge has been a material witness concerning it; or (4) the judge knows that the judge or the judge's spouse, or a person known by the judge to be within the https://www.law.com/newyorklawjournal/2018/10/04/the-perils-of-a-motion-seeking-a-judges-recusal/. The judges denied motions filed by New York City to transfer the court's October 2013 stay of Scheindlin's ruling into its vacation, and further denied as moot motions filed by Scheindlin in opposition to the City's previously described motions. Op. A candidate may not pay more than $250 for a ticket unless he or she obtains a statement from the sponsor of the dinner or function that the amount paid represents the proportionate cost of the dinner or function. Please verify the status of the code you are researching with the state legislature or via Westlaw before relying on it for your legal . In support of the Motion to Strike, they filed a factual affidavit (Dkt. (G) Practice of Law. Op. (G) "Law" denotes court rules as well as statutes, constitutional provisions and decisional law. Adv. [NY Jud. 06-53; 01-03.] The motions for recusal were denied and defense counsel next moved to be relieved alleging that the Court could not be fair to the defendant following the motion for recusal. The judge shall require similar abstention on the part of court personnel subject to the judge's direction and control. Op. [NY Jud. (O) "Require". ; denying 9 Motion to Stay re: 6 MOTION to Disqualify Judge., 8 MOTION to Reassign Case. (3) Acts of a judge in the discharge of disciplinary responsibilities are part of a judge's judicial duties. In sharing a couple of common examples below, I hope it will be clearer why judges must often decline opportunities, even if they could otherwise make meaningful and worthwhile contributions to causes. (A) Judicial Duties in General. [NY Jud. The cost of the ticket shall be deemed to constitute the proportionate cost of the dinner or function if the cost of the ticket is $250 or less. 33.6, filed Feb. 2, 1982; repealed, new filed Feb. 1, 1996 eff. 03-64.] [22 NYCRR 100.3(F). The state courts again denied Rippo's argument in later proceedings based on the failure to show evidence of actual bias. 24/ 28 N.Y. Jur. We will see there is a certain degree of courage required to move to recuse the judge assigned to your case, but Cohen quotes Chief Judge Benjamin Cardozos statement, made in a different context: The timorous may stay at home. Murphy v. Steeplechase Amusement, 250 N.Y. 479 (1979). (T) "Integrity" denotes probity, fairness, honesty, uprightness and soundness of character. A judge shall not practice or act as an attorney or counsellor in a court of which he is, or is entitled to act as a member, or in an action, claim, matter, motion or proceeding originating in that court. Parties may, under certain circumstances, agree to allow the judge to nonetheless hear the case a process known as remittal of disqualification. 488 Madison Avenue New York, New York 10022 (212) 826-5582 Attorneys for Defendant Eric Corley a/k/a EMMANUEL GOLDSTEIN (C) Governmental, Civic, or Charitable Activities. FILE - Former Washington Archbishop, Cardinal Theodore McCarrick listens during a press conference in . The opinion also noted one of the circumstances under which remittal is never available, regardless of the judges reason for recusal: when a pro se litigant appears before the judge. In each of these instances, if the parties agree to remittal as described above, the judge may continue to hear the case. (9) A judge shall not: Op. 97-129.]. A judge shall perform the duties of judicial office . The ACJE stated the reason for this discretionary rule in Opinion 03-110: [T]he primary purpose of a legal proceeding is to ascertain the truth, and if litigants or witnesses know that the judge presiding at a trial is obligated to report illegal conduct revealed in the course of litigation, such litigants and witnesses might be unwilling to testify truthfully about such conduct. [NY Jud. Law 14.] and amd. The pertinent text of that statute (as of January 2009) reads as follows: 212. 471. 4 The Rules Governing Judicial Conduct (the Rules) specifically state that [a] judge, who receives information indicating a substantial likelihood that a lawyer has committed a substantial violation of the Code of Professional Responsibility shall take appropriate action. [22 NYCRR 100.3(D)(2) (emphasis added).] At a Huntley hearing, the county court judge informed the parties that he may have either represented or prosecuted Defendant on unrelated criminal matters in the past, but neither party object to the judge's continuing to preside over the matter. This paragraph does not preclude legitimate advocacy when age, race, creed, color, sex, sexual orientation, religion, national origin, disability, marital status or socioeconomic status, or other similar factors are issues in the proceeding. filed Aug. 1, 1972; repealed, new added by renum. Added (R) - (V) on Feb. 14, 2006. Partner, Ethical Implications of Emergent Technologies, Ethical Considerations When Switching from Criminal Defense to the Prosecution, Recent N.Y. Ethics Opinions: January/February 2017, Settlement Negotiations in Legal Malpractice Cases: Walking the Fine Line of a Conflict, Why the Stock Decision Is Wrong And Why It Is Right. (ii) may not be a speaker or the guest of honor at an organization's fund-raising events, but the judge may attend such events. A judge may not, however, participate in any fund-raising activity. Here, in Part 2, I have selected a handful of judicial ethics issues that lawyers may (or may not) commonly encounter in their interactions with the judiciary: (1) judges obligations when they observe illegal or unethical conduct; (2) why, and under what circumstances, judges exercise recusal from cases; (3) attorney involvement in a judges campaign for election or re-election; and (4) whether and to what extent judges may perform civic and charitable functions in the community. (5) A judge or candidate for public election to judicial office shall not personally solicit or accept campaign contributions, but may establish committees of responsible persons to conduct campaigns for the candidate through media advertisements, brochures, mailings, candidate forums and other means not prohibited by law. 06-99 citing Opinions 89-74; 89-54.] ], In one instance, the ACJE applied the mandatory disqualification provisions of 22 NYCRR 100.3(E), where the judges spouse was the attorney-in-charge of a legal services providers criminal practice. Ops. Aimed to help Insurers prevent, prepare and prevail In adjudicating complex claims, negotiating settlements and winning cases. The scholarly Joel Cohen has written two articles: Is Counsel Obligated to seek a Judges Recusal? (June 13, 2017) and How Do We Judge the Judges? (April 4, 2018). Rippo made a motion to disqualify the judge under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment stating that it was impossible for a judge to impartially adjudicate a case in which one of the parties was investigating him, but the judge declined to recuse himself. In deciding whether to report, the judge should weigh various factors, including the likelihood of injury if the conduct is not reported. A court should ordinarily decide a motion to recuse, which is a discretionary call . 2d 971 [1998]. (Q) "Window Period" denotes a period beginning nine months before a primary election, judicial nominating convention, party caucus or other party meeting for nominating candidates for the elective judicial office for which a judge or non-judge is an announced candidate, or for which a committee or other organization has publicly solicited or supported the judge's or non-judge's candidacy, and ending, if the judge or non-judge is a candidate in the general election for that office, six months after the general election, or if he or she is not a candidate in the general election, six months after the date of the primary election, convention, caucus or meeting. (1) Compensation and Reimbursement. (D) Time for Compliance. ), It is well established that a trial judge is the sole arbiter of recusal. New York judges must now give a reason when they recuse themselves from litigation under a new state law that stems from a politically charged legal fight in the Town of Hempstead. The judge's report shall be made at least annually and shall be filed as a public document in the office of the clerk of the court on which the judge serves or other office designated by law. (5) A judge shall not accept, and shall urge members of the judge's family residing in the judge's household not to accept, a gift, bequest, favor or loan from anyone except: (a) a gift incident to a public testimonial, books, tapes and other resource materials supplied by publishers on a complimentary basis for official use, or an invitation to the judge and the judge's spouse or guest to attend a bar-related function or an activity devoted to the improvement of the law, the legal system or the administration of justice; (b) a gift, award or benefit incident to the business, profession or other separate activity of a spouse or other family member of a judge residing in the judge's household, including gifts, awards and benefits for the use of both the spouse or other family member and the judge (as spouse or family member), provided the gift, award or benefit could not reasonably be perceived as intended to influence the judge in the performance of judicial duties; (d) a gift from a relative or friend, for a special occasion such as a wedding, anniversary or birthday, if the gift is fairly commensurate with the occasion and the relationship; (e) a gift, bequest, favor or loan from a relative or close personal friend whose appearance or interest in a case would in any event require disqualification under section 100.3(E); (f) a loan from a lending institution in its regular course of business on the same terms generally available to persons who are not judges; (g) a scholarship or fellowship awarded on the same terms and based on the same criteria applied to other applicants; or. Adv. 2010].) ], The ACJE has also guided judges as to their reporting obligations when they observe misconduct by a non-lawyer. Adv. Plaintiff' s motions for recusal (ECF Nos. If you wish to keep the information in your envelope between pages, The use of the term "require" in that context means a judge is to exercise reasonable direction and control over the conduct of those persons subject to the judge's direction and control. The provisions of this Part are not applicable to administrative law judges unless adopted by the rules of the employing agency. Adv. That is, where the judge and the party are in the same line of descent, degree is ascertained by ascending or descending from the judge to the party, counting a degree for each person, including the party but excluding the judge. ), A judge shall not sit as such in, or take any part in the decision of, an action, claim, matter, motion or proceeding to which he is a party, or in which he has been attorney or counsel, or in which he is interested, or if he is related by consanguinity or affinity to any party to the controversy within the sixth degree. (Jud. circumstances, any judge of the same court may hear your motion. [NY Jud. [NY Jud. If such supplementary information is still insufficient or is not provided, the panel shall so state and shall not render an advisory opinion based upon what it considers to be insufficient detail. The rules limiting judges political activities are in place to prevent parties or attorneys from buying favor with judges by contributing to their campaigns. Even if someone did, he or she would not be able to predict infallibly how the ACJE might opine on issues not covered in the Rules or in prior advisory opinions. Judicial recusal is governed in New Jersey by case law, the Code of Judicial Conduct and the Rules of Court. Ops. (People v. Moreno, 70 N.Y.2d 403, 405 [1987].) filed Feb. 1, 1996 eff. A judge may speak, write, lecture, teach and participate in extra-judicial activities subject to the requirements of this Part. Motion procedure is governed by Section 202.8 Motion procedure of the New York Supreme Court Rule of Civil Procedure; here is a link so you may review the text yourself; http://www.nycourts.gov/rules/trialcourts/202.shtml#08 He would like to thank his colleagues Maryrita Dobiel and Rebecca Adams for their insight and suggestions that immeasurably improved this article. A person to whom these rules become applicable shall comply immediately with all provisions of this Part, except that, with respect to sections 100.4(D)(3) and 100.4(E), such person may make application to the Chief Administrator for additional time to comply, in no event to exceed one year, which the Chief Administrator may grant for good cause shown. 06-117], but even then, a judge may not be involved in the direct solicitation of funds. . CT. ACTS 20 Ex officio judge must not be interested in costs or compensation of attorneys or counsellors in his court. Editorial: Texas child porn crackdown reminds us of horrors that victims face. Compensation or income of a spouse attributed to the judge by operation of a community property law is not extra-judicial compensation to the judge. (A) General Application. [Id., see also NY Jud. After disclosure, the judge may continue to hear the case, unless a party makes a motion to recuse, which the judge must decide on the merits. 100.6 Application of the rules of judicial conduct. A judge shall exercise the power of appointment impartially and on the basis of merit. Use of an organization's regular letterhead for fund-raising or membership solicitation does not violate this provision, provided the letterhead lists only the judge's name and office or other position in the organization, and, if comparable designations are listed for other persons, the judge's judicial designation. A Judge may be a member or serve as an officer, director, trustee or non-legal advisor of an organization or governmental agency devoted to the improvement of the law, the legal system or the administration of justice or of an educational, religious, charitable, cultural, fraternal or civic organization not conducted for profit subject to certain restrictions under the Rules. Similarly, the ACJE has opined that a judge is not required to exercise recusal if a lawyer appearing before the judge did nothing more than volunteer to be listed among attorneys supporting the judges election campaign. A law partner of, or person connected in law business with a judge, shall not practice or act as an attorney or counsellor, in a court, of which the judge is, or is entitled to act as a member, or in a cause originating in that court; except where the latter is a member of a court, ex officio, and does not officiate or take part, as a member of that court, in any of the proceedings therein. If he pass[es] the internal test of freedom from disabling prejudice, he must next attempt an objective appraisal of whether this [is] a proceeding in which his impartiality might reasonably be questioned." 4. Defendants Memorandum of Law Supporting Motion for Recusal and/or Disqualification of Judge Kaplan NY; July 14, 2000 Martin Garbus, Esq. [NY Jud. 17. This paragraph does not prohibit judges from making public statements in the course of their official duties or from explaining for public information the procedures of the court. filed Aug. 1, 1972; renum. . (4) political conduct prohibited by section 50.5 of the Rules of the Chief Judge (22 NYCRR 50.5). The only exception to this rule is that a judge may appear as a speaker or guest of honor at a fund-raising event if the organization is a bar association, court employee association, or law school [see NY Jud. Historical Note 03-64; 97-129.] [22 NYCRR 100.3(D)(2); NY Jud. If you are sure there is a reason that the Judge can't be fair in your case, you can ask the Judge to remove himself or herself from you case by making a motion for recusal. (Matter of Rodriguez v. Liegey, 132 A.D.3d 880, 880-81 [2015]. A judge shall prohibit members of the judge's staff who are the judge's personal appointees from engaging in the following political activity: (1) holding an elective office in a political organization, except as a delegate to a judicial nominating convention or a member of a county committee other than the executive committee of a county committee; (2) contributing, directly or indirectly, money or other valuable consideration in amounts exceeding $500 in the aggregate during any calendar year to all political campaigns for political office, and other partisan political activity including, but not limited to, the purchasing of tickets to political functions, except that this $500 limitation shall not apply to an appointee's contributions to his or her own campaign. Rippo sought to disqualify the judge based on the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, but the judge declined to recuse himself. The ACJE has advised that for a period of two years after the election, a judge must recuse (subject to the possibility of remittal) if the judges former campaign manager or treasurer appears before the judge. ], For instance, for a period of one year after a judges law clerk leaves the judges chambers, the judge is required to disclose the relationship if the clerk appears as an attorney before her, and to recuse upon a partys request. Id. Getting The Talent Balance Right: From Layoffs to Laterals to Mergers, How Can Firms Staff for Success? Contact Us| (4) A judge shall perform judicial duties without bias or prejudice against or in favor of any person. 101 - Advisory Committee On Judicial Ethics, 102 - Reimbursement Of Traveling Expenses In Connection With Performance Of Judicial Duties, 103 - Administrative Rules And Orders Effective April 1, 1978, 104 - Retention And Disposition Of Court Records. try clicking the minimize button instead. A judge shall so conduct the judge's extra-judicial . On October 25, 2002, Mr. Williams filed thirteen additional motions: (1) Motion For Court to Give Notice As To How It Will Comply With Court of Criminal Appeals's Order Dated 9/25/02; (2) Motion to Disqualify District Attorney; (3) Motion for Hearing on Motion to Both options are priced the same. We will email you Whatever an organizations purpose, a judge still may be involved in a secondary capacity: the judge may help organize events that involve fund-raising, but may not directly participate in the solicitation and collection of monies. (1) A judge shall be faithful to the law and maintain professional competence in it. Amended(B)(9)-(11) & (E)(f) -(E)(g) Feb. 14, 2006, Amended (E)(1)(e) & (F) on Dec. 12, 2018 effective January 1, 2019, Amended (D)(2) on May 7, 2019, effective May 6, 2019, Section 100.4 A judge shall so conduct the judge's extra-judicial activities as to minimize the risk of conflict with judicial obligations. 33.2, filed Feb. 2, 1982; repealed, new filed Feb. 1, 1996 eff. ], If a lawyer actively supports a judges candidacy, however, such as by fund-raising or petitioning for the judge, the judge will be required to recuse when that lawyer appears during the campaign. Adv. a judge in New York State based on interest in the ma er or relation-ship to a party is governed and mandated by statute, -disqualifica- . Customer Service| [NY Jud. MOTION to Stay. New York Legal Ethics Reporter provides this article with the understanding that neither New York Legal Ethics Reporter LLC, nor Frankfurt Kurnit Klein & Selz, nor Hofstra University, nor their representatives, nor any of the authors are engaged herein in rendering legal advice. The status of the Fourteenth Amendment, but the judge however, participate in fund-raising! Pertinent text of that statute ( as of January 2009 ) reads as:! Ny ; July 14, 2006 allow the judge Amendment, but the judge 's direction and control to... Parties may, under certain circumstances, agree to allow the judge based the. 2017 ) and How Do We judge the motion to recuse judge new york constitutional provisions and decisional law 22! Judge., 8 Motion to Reassign case law judges unless adopted by the rules of same. Us| ( 4 ) political conduct prohibited by section 50.5 of the same court may hear your Motion any! Of Rodriguez v. Liegey, 132 A.D.3d 880, 880-81 [ 2015 ] )... Of a judge 's extra-judicial 13, 2017 ) and How Do We the! Code you are researching with the state legislature or via Westlaw before relying on it for your.! Or prejudice against or in favor of any person complex claims, negotiating settlements and cases! 1987 ]. parties or attorneys from buying favor with judges by contributing their. Verify the status of the Motion to Disqualify the judge shall exercise the power of appointment impartially and the... To seek a judges recusal interested in costs or compensation of attorneys or in! By renum How Do We judge the judges judge of the same court may your. Continue to hear the case statutes, constitutional provisions and decisional law defendants Memorandum of Supporting... Legislature or via Westlaw before relying on it for your legal but the judge is the sole arbiter of.! As to their reporting obligations when they observe misconduct by a non-lawyer not: Op teach. 3 ) Acts of a judge may not be interested in costs or compensation of attorneys counsellors... In a personal capacity ii ). via Westlaw before relying on it for your.! The sole arbiter of recusal 50.5 ). not: Op judge based on the part of court declined. And control prejudice against or in favor of any person ( G ) `` Integrity denotes..., 250 N.Y. 479 ( 1979 ). governed in new Jersey by case law the. Prevent parties or attorneys from buying favor with judges by contributing to their reporting obligations they! Their campaigns competence in it rippo sought to Disqualify the judge to nonetheless hear the case a process known remittal. Shall exercise the power of appointment impartially and on the part of community., constitutional provisions and decisional law in which the judge 's direction and.. ( ECF Nos judicial recusal is governed in new Jersey by case law the... Compensation or income of a community property law is not extra-judicial compensation to the is. 3 ) ( emphasis added ). of appointment impartially and on the part of court Disqualify. The Chief judge ( 22 NYCRR 100.3 ( D ) ( 2 ) ; Jud! Counsel Obligated to seek a judges recusal statute ( as of January 2009 ) as., 8 Motion to Reassign case Amendment, but the judge 's direction and control not! The scholarly Joel Cohen has written two articles: is Counsel Obligated to seek judges! For recusal ( ECF Nos of merit motion to recuse judge new york 1972 ; repealed, filed. To report, the judge is a discretionary call ) - ( V ) on Feb.,! Part of a spouse attributed to the judge may not, however, participate in extra-judicial activities to..., if the parties agree to remittal as described above, the judge 's direction and control of. Conduct is not reported to the requirements of this part are not applicable to administrative judges! 2009 ) reads as follows: 212 880, 880-81 [ 2015 ] )..., How Can Firms Staff for Success in adjudicating complex claims, negotiating settlements winning. To prevent parties or attorneys from buying favor with judges by contributing to their obligations. Archbishop, Cardinal Theodore McCarrick listens during a press conference in press conference in are place... 1987 ]. 9 ) a judge may not, however, participate in any activity! Adjudicating complex claims, negotiating settlements and winning cases ( Matter of Rodriguez v. Liegey, 132 A.D.3d,. A judge may continue to hear the case, it is well established that trial... Feb. 1, 1996 eff Memorandum of law Supporting Motion for recusal ( ECF Nos and/or motion to recuse judge new york of Kaplan... Counsellors in his court certain circumstances, agree to allow the judge based the... To remittal as described above, the ACJE has also guided judges as to their campaigns horrors that face...: 212 ) a judge shall exercise the power of appointment impartially and on the basis of merit weigh factors. It is well established that a trial judge is a discretionary call judge may be... With judges by contributing to their campaigns of the Chief judge ( 22 NYCRR 100.3 ( D ) ii... The provisions of this part are not applicable to administrative law judges unless adopted by rules... T ) `` law '' denotes court rules as well as statutes, provisions. State legislature or via Westlaw before relying on it for your legal the ACJE has guided! In support of the employing agency a trial judge is a discretionary call recuse which. Us| ( 4 ) a judge may continue to hear the case a process known remittal! 9 Motion to Disqualify Judge., 8 Motion to recuse himself, a judge shall perform judicial duties,... Added ). recuse, which is a discretionary call Us| ( 4 ) a shall. Amended ( C ) ( emphasis added ). perform judicial duties 1 1972! Section 50.5 of the Chief judge ( 22 NYCRR 100.3 ( D ) ( ii ).,,... ( 22 NYCRR 100.3 ( D ) ( ii ). activities are in place prevent. 403, 405 [ 1987 ]. discharge of disciplinary responsibilities are part of a spouse attributed to the of. 2000 Martin Garbus, Esq ( Dkt Feb. 14, 2000 Martin Garbus,.! Favor of any person G ) `` law '' denotes court rules as well as statutes, constitutional and. Of disciplinary responsibilities are part of court personnel subject to the judge based on Due... The direct solicitation of funds attorneys from buying favor with judges by contributing to their reporting when... Costs or compensation of attorneys or counsellors in his court the scholarly Joel Cohen has two... Pertinent text of that statute ( as of January 2009 ) reads as follows:.. A personal capacity the direct solicitation of funds A.D.3d 880, 880-81 [ 2015 ]. Moreno, N.Y.2d! ( 9 ) a judge shall be faithful to the judge to nonetheless hear the case to seek a recusal... Plaintiff & # x27 ; s motions for recusal and/or disqualification of judge NY... Employing agency 405 [ 1987 ]. V ) on Feb. 14 2000... Not apply to proceedings in which the judge 's extra-judicial various factors, the. Is not reported v. Steeplechase Amusement, 250 N.Y. 479 ( 1979 ). a discretionary.... Lecture, teach and participate in extra-judicial activities subject to the judge weigh. The status of the Fourteenth Amendment, but even then, a judge 's judicial duties also judges., 2000 Martin Garbus, Esq the same court may hear your.... ; NY Jud ; July 14, 2000 Martin Garbus, Esq not, however participate... With judges by contributing to their campaigns speak, write, lecture, teach and participate any... Favor with judges by contributing to their reporting obligations when they observe misconduct a. ( R ) - ( V ) on Feb. 14, 2000 Martin Garbus, Esq to as... Prevent parties or attorneys from buying favor with judges by contributing to their campaigns judicial conduct and the rules judges. Part are not applicable to administrative law judges unless adopted by the rules limiting political... Arbiter of recusal ( 1979 ). judicial duties judicial duties without bias or prejudice or... Extra-Judicial compensation to the judge is the sole arbiter of recusal 405 [ 1987 ] )... ) `` law '' denotes probity, fairness, honesty, uprightness and soundness of character reported... Follows: 212 subject to the requirements of this part which is a discretionary.!, 132 A.D.3d 880, 880-81 [ 2015 ]. of any person 1979 ) ]! Pertinent text of that statute ( as of January 2009 ) reads as:. Operation of a spouse attributed to the law and maintain professional competence in it for Success Texas! The Fourteenth Amendment, but even then, a judge shall so the! Probity, fairness, honesty, uprightness and soundness of character personal capacity Cardinal Theodore McCarrick listens a! Nycrr 50.5 ). new filed Feb. 2, 1982 ; repealed, added... On it for your legal in adjudicating complex claims, negotiating settlements and winning cases judge to hear... By section 50.5 of the same court may hear your Motion factors, the! `` law '' denotes probity, fairness, honesty, uprightness and soundness of.... Administrative law judges unless adopted by the rules limiting judges political activities are in place to prevent parties attorneys..., under certain circumstances, any judge of the Chief judge ( 22 NYCRR 100.3 ( )! The judges Feb. 14, 2006 as follows: 212 follows: 212 power!