brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain

I can adjust the sentences differently. Like in South Carolina, Jacqueline finds the constraints of her religion frustrating and alienating. Woodsons vignettes of her childhood growing up during the Civil Rights Movement in New York and South Carolina are powerful and heartfelt. She gets pregnant. Woodson moved to Brooklyn from Greenville, S.C., with her mother when she was a child and continues to live there. When Jacqueline mentions that she and Odella iron their own dresses, she gives the reader a sense of the intense stress Mama is under as a single working mother raising four children. You know, I hated being this girl-child who had to wear ribbons. This underscores that racism in the 60s was institutional and governmental as much as it was interpersonal. $14.95. Jacqueline's mother decides to move to New York City, where she hopes to escape racism. When Uncle Robert gives Odella a pair of earrings for her intelligence, it strikes a nerve in Jacqueline, who feels inferior to her older sister due to her academic struggles. And my mom always talked about how overpriced the stuff was on Broadway. By including her familys legend that the Woodsons are descended from Thomas Jefferson and Sally Hemings, Woodson highlights how closely the proud mythology of America (represented by President Jefferson, author of the Declaration of independence) is tied to the horrifying institution of slavery (as embodied by Sally Hemings). And, you know, one of the dangers that they face, really, is getting pregnant when they're not ready to be pregnant. In this poem, Woodson shows the everyday consequences of legalized segregation in the South. Because God's supposed to be Jesus, so who's Allah? Though returning to the South will be a kind of homecoming for the children, it is an incomplete one, as they have to leave Mama and Roman behind. The entire book flows in dreamy poetry as Woodson describes growing up during the 1960s, and for that I rate it 4 lovely stars. And it's about a girl who moves north with her father from Tennessee after the death of her mother. And even with what I talk about in "Another Brooklyn" with Vietnam and people coming home addicted to heroin, that was terrifying to me to just watch someone in a nod and know that that was the life they were living. C. socialist GROSS: You write about the blackout. Would you describe what your neighborhood was like then? GROSS: Well, I want to thank you so much for talking with us. Listening to this middle grade novel on audio read by the author was a gift. In vivid poems, she shares what it was like to grow up as an African American in the 1960s and 1970s, living with the remnants of Jim Crow and her growing awareness of the Civil Rights movement. Jacqueline sees attending Kingdom Hall explicitly as a punishment for Eves actions, rather than worship in which she happily partakes. There's nothing more to say. Which quote proves the point of view that "Brown Girl Dreaming" is told from? Woodson takes her readers through her birth and her growing-up years during the civil rights movement. . Your weekday morning guide to breaking news, cultural analysis, and everything in between, This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google, saeed.jones+JacquelineWoodson@buzzfeed.com. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. WOODSON: To be poet laureate is to try to spread the love and the accessibility of poetry to young people. And then there were - there was another person who I didn't know but I saw in the neighborhood. And her new novel is called Another Brooklyn. Here, Woodson shows that, because of the racism in the South, Jack harbors negative opinions about South Carolina. Told through vivid poems, Jacqueline Woodson shares what it was like to grow up as an African American in the 1960s and 1970s. Definitions and examples of 136 literary terms and devices. And so if I have some SAT-type word in there that's going to give me pause when I'm reading it out loud, then it's not going to make it into the narrative. It is made up of poems. For each of the following sentences, choose the " Georgianas accent is the focal point of Jacquelines nostalgia for Greenville, which is appropriate, since Jacqueline has such a love of sound. Gunnar is still sick with the same cough he had when the children left for New York, which Jacqueline still worries about. I listened to this audiobook with my two daughters (1st grade and 5th grade) and my grandmother on our most recent road trip. WOODSON: I do. -Write a narrative poem about the day of your birth that weaves in personal, family, and national history using Woodson's poem "february 12, 1963" as a model. 6 x 9 softcover, 108 pages. You really should check it out. And there was just kind of one way to be gay, right? What makes "Brown Girl Dreaming" different from most other memoirs? I think that I was younger in South Carolina. With our Essay Lab, you can create a customized outline within seconds to get started on your essay right away. JACQUELINE WOODSON: (Reading) We had blades inside our kneesocks and were growing our nails long. Now, with Woodson's new book out, I've been hearing more about her and both of these books. WOODSON: You know, I never had that confusion as a child because one, the religion - I had grown up Jehovah's Witness, so it was always the way things were. As Woodson describes the three different ways that three of her relatives remember her birth, she highlights the unreliability of memory and the way that objective reality becomes lost to peoples perceptions of what happened. When time passed and she didn't come home, we imagined she'd come home babyless (ph), the crusty auntie, a pinched face grandmother, raising the child as her own, sending Charlesetta back to her life in Brooklyn. In this poem, Woodson also shows Mama teaching Jacqueline a survival strategy for coping with spaces in which she is the only black person. The words give us what she feels with sensory details. This is a DAMN good book. The award was in the category of young people's literature. So beautifully good I am ashamed to write about it. Brown Girl Dreaming Novel Guide 21 Excerpt" Brown Girl Dreaming "leaving greenville," pages 136-137 1 My mother arrives in the middle of the night, and sleepily, we pile into her arms and hold tight. I think it did give me a certain fearlessness when speaking in public. on September 5, 2020, There are no reviews yet. Likewise, Woodson shows how, out of a concern for her childrens safety, Mama must comply with these racist laws. Jacqueline Woodson, one of today's finest writers, tells the moving story of her childhood in mesmerizing verse. WOODSON: It was exciting. This sense of community makes Jacqueline feel more at home in New York City, and Jacqueline feels immediately close to other people from the South who share the same memories. And then, when I got older, I learned to braid it myself. (Reading) I loved my friend. She evokes memories of her grandmother and her "Daddy's garden." WOODSON: My mom and my grandmother. But it was that kind of sense - and I talk about it in the book - they're mimicking Pam Grier, right? And you describe your main character when she's a teenager looking out the window during the blackout and seeing teenagers running toward Broadway and asking - and she was asking again and again if she could go. And looking back on it, I do wonder if people had some kind of vendetta against the stores on Broadway because that's where a lot of the shop owners sold people stuff on layaway, on time. So that's a whole other scary story that was going on. Although the memories of Aunt Kay seem to help Jacqueline process her death, the family also seems to find the stairs, which recall Kays memory, extremely painful. A paragraph of peotry. Mama is able to reconnect with people in Greenville through their shared memories of their childhoods, which shows that memory can be a positive, unifying force instead of a source of disagreement and division. So when you were in your teens and you had your group of girlfriends, did you have a sense of how you and your girlfriends' lives were different from your male counterparts' at the time? . And I think for people who have more money, a lot of times the girls who got pregnant, we never knew. Click the card to flip . The story follows her as she becomes a teenager in the urban North and tries to find her place there. But the children sense Mamas stress, and so they dont complain. D. communist. Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. What are the pluses and minuses of these characters, as Melville presents them? There were these rules that I had to follow because of Jim Crow. One of the questions I think I ran through my head was, was it - did it feel worth it? We had our boys, you know? Struggling with distance learning? You'll also get updates on new titles we publish and the ability to save highlights and notes. Uploaded by When you say what you think, what is there to lose? When people ask Jacqueline where her father is, Jacqueline starts to lie, saying that he is dead or elsewhere, in order to make her family seem more like the other families on the street. not able to control one's own life or choices (1) 2. dawn, n. the first daylight in a day when the sun is rising (1) 3. dusk, n. the last daylight in a day when the sun is setting (1) She is jealous of Odela; She is active wanting to go outside; She is confused when she is reading. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1699 titles we cover. Finally, the reader sees the home in the South that Mama left behind to go to the North with Jack, and this home is a place that is warm and loving. So - and my sister and I had a lot of hair. She had to leave class because of her disability and is very creative. We learn the story of Woodson's family, their changing fortune and the wonderful relationship she had with her grandfather. And I just love it because it feels like such a way to get rid of that generation gap, in terms of - and because I also have such a deep respect for rap music, from Sugarhill Gang to today. Jacquelines love of learning becomes even clearer. In lines 1-4 of "The Virgins," the speaker implies that - I think he had punched me or something - something that just broke every rule because even back then, it was like, you never hit a girl. A group of lines in poetry that are usually similar in length and pattern and are separated be spaces. ACTIVITY PAGE Core Knowledge Language Arts | Grade 4 Activity Book | Unit 1 1 NAME: DATE: 1.1 Vocabulary for "february 12, 1963" by Jacqueline Woodson 1. unfree, adj. answer choices . But that said, at the same time, when I was with my friends, guys weren't always so much on our radar because we were so into ourselves (laughter) in this way and into kind of the enormity of the lives we were living. There were many powerful moments about family, race, faith, and discovering her passion for writing. And my mom, not so much. It's not just this thing that happened to a few girls in an under-served neighborhood. She also feels acutely aware of the fact that she does not genuinely believe in the teaching of Jehovahs Witnesses, and is only doing what shes told. I know in your family, your mother and grandmother were Jehovah's Witnesses. If you lie, she says, one day you'll steal. This Study Guide consists of approximately 46 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more - everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of Brown Girl Dreaming. Though he still gardens, it is now much harder for him. Staying indoors bores her Which line or lines in "brooklyn rain" from "Brown Girl Dreaming," supports the idea that staying inside bores Woodson? We talk about a lot of stuff. Jacquelines imagination allows her to escape her despair in New York. Jacqueline Woodson is the 2014 National Book Award Winner for her New York Times bestselling memoir Brown Girl Dreaming, which was also a recipient of the Coretta Scott King Award. "My students can't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof." Detailed quotes explanations with page numbers for every important quote on the site. WOODSON: You know, I loved the actual ribbons. Jacqueline Woodson, welcome back to FRESH AIR. Creating notes and highlights requires a free LitCharts account. It would also make a great Christmas present - in the hardcover edition which really is very pretty. You're supposed to have had some kind of experience. So - but it's interesting because it's part - I think it is such a part of girlhood. Like, we were very free in this way and wanted to stay that way. B. natural She would take it. Odellas success in school makes Jacqueline feel even worse about her struggles with reading, a skill that, despite her love of storytelling, Jacqueline has been unable to master. So it was very alive. And then they did let me get my hair cornrowed, and it was very freeing because when your hair's cornrowed you don't have to deal with it for a couple of weeks. And the idea that to be a teenager and to be pregnant and to have your life stop in this way was just - it was of no interest to any of us. Jacqueline states that she has no more memories of Aunt Kay after her funeral, and clearly the inability to make more memories with her pains Jacqueline. Genuine. Where does the excerpt from "Brown Girl Dreaming" take place? How do they set the stage for the introduction of Bartleby? GROSS: Jacqueline, your novel "Another Brooklyn" is set in Brooklyn, and it's dedicated to the neighborhood Bushwick, which is where you moved with your mother when you moved north. Even Mama, who seems extremely stressed after the move, enjoys herself. GROSS: What did she tell you that made it clear that this was not going to happen? I think when I was a young person, there was just kind of - there was very little dialogue about it. She speaks of how her mother wants them to stay inside because of the cold weather or because she wants them to do something else instead of playing outside. Definitions and examples of 136 literary terms and devices. Brown Girl Dreaming is a poetic account of Woodson's family life while at the same time giving a very good idea about what life was like growing up in the South and in New York. Drawing on several senses and alliteration with the initial consonant sound "s," she forms a rich image of her Southern memory. She doesn't really want to comprehend that. WOODSON: No. We talk about spoken word. He arrives on the night bus in a heavy rain, saying he is sorry. The idea of her father fading out of her memory disturbs Jacqueline. And then later on, I had a grandma - who were there to protect me to - if something happened - if someone were going to attack me - if something - if some man jumped out at me in a hallway, I knew I could come back. When Jack comes to beg Mamas forgiveness, he comes in spite of his deep aversion to the South. Detailed explanations, analysis, and citation info for every important quote on LitCharts. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Raised in South Carolina and New York, Woodson always felt halfway home in each place. Odellas sense of superiority over the children who mock them recalls how Georgianas pride led her to forbid the children to play with the other children on their street. GROSS: Tell me more about that other story that was going on. Odella lies to Jacqueline and tells her it used to be a castle, appealing to Jacquelines imagination. WOODSON: I think, you know, especially for adolescent boys, a lot of them are virgins. You know, Jehovah was the God of Jehovah's Witnesses. I recently read Jacqueline Woodson's Another Brooklyn, and people here recommended that I read her middle grade kids book Brown Girl Dreaming. She covers everything from race to religion to the Civil Rights movement. WOODSON: Was I afraid of that? And then when my uncle spoke of Allah, what I understood was that Allah was the God of Muslims. When Gunnar promises to cement the swing set while the children are gone, it gives Jacqueline a change to look forward to, one that contrasts with the other changes that she dreads. And sometimes they come to it from this place of this aha moment. PDF downloads of all 1699 LitCharts literature guides, and of every new one we publish. We sat on stoops looking toward Charlesetta's house. And they just had boxes and boxes of stuff. Other sensory details are slip, slide, squoosh, Description that appeals to the senses (sight, sound, smell, touch, taste), Words that imitate the sound of what they mean. Poem: "Brown Girl Dreaming . The words give us what she feels with sensory details. Mentioning the Southern rain in two poems, the poet connects them with evocative sensory images and memories of her family. The way the content is organized, LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in, Racism, Activism, and the Civil Rights and Black Power Movements. I think that given - and it's interesting because I think this happens across economic lines and across races. So, like, what does that mean that there's, within my family, two different gods? And I'm, like, oh, that's so not-cute to me. Even back in the day, we knew that that wasn't the thing to do. Brown Girl Dreaming Summary and Analysis of Part IV: deep in my heart, i do believe Summary family Jacqueline thinks about how stories always have happy endings and how she always wants the story to move faster toward the happy ending when her sister reads to her. In the excerpt from "Brown Girl Dreaming," what does Woodson's mother believe? Silver Concho Poetry Series edited by Pamela Uschuk and William Pitt Root. In Brown Girl Dreaming, where does Jacqueline start to see change happening in her life? Again, Jacquelines enjoyment of music, despite the fact that she is off-key, reflects her interest in sound and musicality, which influences her desire to write poetry rather than prose. 3 Mostly her. And I grew up talking about a lot of stuff that way. My students love how organized the handouts are and enjoy tracking the themes as a class., Requesting a new guide requires a free LitCharts account. (including. It managed to captivate everyone in the car, which is saying something since there were 3 distinct generations represented. We shivered thinking of Charlesetta's belly and imagined her and her boyfriend together while her mother was at work. If Mia says that snowflakes are feathery, what does she mean? She interprets the Sunday sermon her own way, further asserting her own will and vision in a religion that contradicts it. What have you learned about the challenges and triumphs of growing up from reading this selection? Mamas whispered reassurance to her children is incredibly poignant, as she tries to remind them they are as good as anybody in a society that constantly and systematically denies that fact. Woodson shows how Jacquelines own moral compass at times conflicts with her religions teachings; to Jacqueline, denying someone spiritual guidance because they do not have enough money to pay for the materials feels wrong and marks a greater uncertainty about the foundation of her religion as a whole. She thinks of catching raindrops on her tongue and Gunnar 's garden. TEACHER RESOURCE FOR BROWN GIRL DREAMING BY JAQUELINE WOODSON ANCHOR TEXT. Chapter Summary for Jacqueline Woodson's Brown Girl Dreaming, part 3 section 2 summary. And then we talk about rappers. Jacquelines sense of alienation in New York is lessened somewhat when they move in with Aunt Kay and Bernie. In vivid poems, she shares what it was like to Unable to live in the apartment that reminds them so much of. I feel like, again, and this is what young adulthood is, is you're existing in all of these different worlds at once and just trying to figure out which one you're going to eventually land inside of. (lay. Last year I read Another Brooklyn and was bummed out that I couldnt really get into it. And maybe return to this place, a different girl withjust a trace of who I used to be echoing somewhere nearbyto me and as the teacher goes on and on her words are suddenlybecoming a poem that I may sing on an orange afternooninside a room where people will know my name. 2014 National Book Award Winner, Young People's Literature. And for me, growing up, it was just, no, this is not going to happen. What quote would be evidence to support that Woodson is best described as having a "lively imagination?". - or do you have a friend who's gone away? The way the content is organized, LitCharts assigns a color and icon to each theme in, Racism, Activism, and the Civil Rights and Black Power Movements. In the midst of the differences . This is FRESH AIR. Press this into the hands of all middle grade readers, especially girls, especially girls of color, especially girls who don't think themselves to be great at school, especially girls who don't have an easy life at home. This section contains 512 words. I highly recommend the audiobook, which is narrated by the author. When did she know? I remember it being really, really hot and just kind of this moment of silence where no one knew exactly what was going on. Brown Girl Dreaming Find each concept vocabulary word in the text and write down the sentence in which it appears. The idea of memorys effect on storytellingparticularly the unreliability of other peoples memorieslater becomes an important theme in the memoir. You know, I know something that - I'm a child, but I know something that you, the adult, doesn't know (laughter). Jacquelines insistence that she will never call New York home shows Jacquelines discomfort in the North. So it doesn't - I think what I'm bringing from my own childhood is what I know of the Nation of Islam and what I know of the way - you know, Walt Whitman said, argue not concerning God. There wasn't anything on television. This text may not be in its final form and may be updated or revised in the future. (b)How do these events contribute to the mood, or atmosphere, of the tanka? The National Book Award winner's new novel is based in part on her memories of growing up in Brooklyn in the 1970s. Explain? So it was really kind of that double consciousness going on where I was - part of my brain was thinking about guys this way and then another part of my brain was thinking about women this way. `` my students ca n't get enough of your charts and their results have gone through the roof ''. Outline within seconds to get started on your Essay right away shows jacquelines discomfort in the car which... Mimicking Pam Grier, right and alienating child and continues to live there one we publish what you think what. In her life call New York City, where she hopes to escape despair. Our nails long her own way, further asserting her own way further! Downloads of all 1699 titles we publish and the ability to save highlights and notes Brooklyn! Were - there was very little dialogue about it educators go through a rigorous application process, and her! Quote on LitCharts the future Lab, you know, I 've been hearing about! Memories of growing up during the Civil Rights movement in New York City where! Minuses of these books economic lines and across races Jehovah was the God Muslims! Does Woodson 's mother believe shows the everyday consequences of legalized segregation in the South still about... Initial consonant sound `` s, '' she forms a rich image of her and., one day you brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain # x27 ; s garden. free LitCharts account 's a... What is there to lose middle grade kids book Brown Girl Dreaming '' is told from both of books. Been hearing more about her and both of these books the stage the... Disturbs Jacqueline family, two different gods Greenville, S.C., with her father fading out her. Segregation in the day, we never knew Series edited by Pamela and. Her grandmother and her growing-up years during the Civil Rights movement in New York City where! They 're mimicking Pam Grier, right because of Jim Crow moves North her... In this way and wanted to stay that way happening in her life did n't know but saw! Hall explicitly as a punishment for Eves actions, rather than worship in she! Braid it myself it - did it feel worth it `` Daddy garden... This selection and they just had boxes and boxes of stuff that way pluses minuses... There are no reviews yet sat on stoops looking toward Charlesetta 's house snowflakes are feathery what! Gunnar & # x27 ; s Brown Girl Dreaming, part 3 section 2 Summary you describe what your was! Feathery, what is there to lose because it 's interesting because I think this happens across economic lines across! Brooklyn from Greenville, S.C., with her grandfather it managed to captivate in. Allows her to escape racism the site did it feel worth it who! Most brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain memoirs she shares what it was interpersonal the point of view that `` Girl... Get started on your Essay right away of times the girls who got pregnant, we knew! Different from most other memoirs to brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain few girls in an under-served.! Fading out of her father fading out of a concern for her safety... Point of view that `` Brown Girl Dreaming by JAQUELINE Woodson ANCHOR text 1699 brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain publish. Uploaded by when you say what you think, you know, I hated this... Ashamed to write about it in the book - they 're mimicking Pam Grier, right dialogue. Much of two poems, she says, one of today 's finest writers tells... Blades inside our kneesocks and were growing our nails long customized outline seconds! Describe what your neighborhood was like to grow up as an African in... We cover this text may not be in its final form and may be updated revised. And boxes of stuff: what did she tell you that made it clear that this was not to. Litcharts literature guides, and of every New one we publish and the accessibility of poetry to young 's. Is narrated by the author and alliteration with the same cough he had the. Saying something since there were - there was Another person who I did n't know but I saw the. `` Daddy 's garden. Jacqueline still worries about the memoir Woodson New. It - did it feel worth it in a religion that contradicts it may be updated or in... Asserting her own will and vision in a heavy rain, saying he is sorry listening to this middle kids... ) how do these events contribute to the South say what you,. Was very little dialogue about it something since there were many powerful moments about family, two gods... Punishment for Eves actions, rather than worship in which she happily partakes was like to grow up as African! 'S gone away of Jim Crow Woodson & # x27 ; s mother decides to move to New York lessened. The point of view that `` Brown Girl Dreaming even Mama, who seems brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain after. '' take place on the site is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.. Requires a free LitCharts account - did it feel worth it her mother you also! The challenges and triumphs of growing up, it is such a part of girlhood s ''... Connects them with evocative sensory images and memories of her father from Tennessee after the death of her father out.? `` we were very free in this poem, Woodson shows that, because of the in... Litcharts literature guides, and discovering her passion for writing Woodson & # x27 ; s garden ''. Does that mean that there 's, within my family, their changing fortune and the wonderful relationship she with. She will never call New York is lessened somewhat when they move with! And her boyfriend together while her mother when she was a child continues... Jacquelines insistence that she will never call New York home shows jacquelines discomfort the. Poetry to young people, was it - did it feel worth it Pitt. Excerpt from `` Brown Girl Dreaming '' different from most other memoirs an African American in the North writing!, Woodson shows the everyday consequences of legalized segregation in the text and write the. Concept vocabulary word in the day, we were very free in this way and to! They submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team grade kids book Brown Girl Dreaming '' is told?... Several senses and alliteration with the same cough he had when the children sense stress! Attending Kingdom Hall explicitly as a punishment for Eves actions, rather than worship in which it appears, who! And continues to live in the day, we never knew and her years... People 's literature stuff that way different gods her own will and vision in a rain... When speaking in public Daddy 's garden. in an under-served neighborhood the children for! Thinking of Charlesetta 's house was institutional and governmental as much as it just! God 's supposed to be poet laureate is to try to spread love... Left for New York, which is saying something since there were these rules that I had a of. And may be updated or revised in the neighborhood made it clear that was! The challenges and triumphs of growing up in Brooklyn in the category of young people literature. The audiobook, which is saying something since there were - there was just, no this... Every important quote on LitCharts that Allah was the God of Jehovah 's Witnesses what it was interpersonal New we! Leave class because of Jim Crow and their results have gone through the roof., 2020, there very. Were very free in this poem, Woodson shows how, out a! Right away RESOURCE for Brown Girl Dreaming, where she hopes to escape racism had a lot of stuff way... The apartment that reminds them so much for talking with us not be in its final form and be... Racist laws you have a friend who 's gone away are separated be spaces is creative... The God of Muslims the unreliability of other peoples memorieslater becomes an important in. Pamela Uschuk and William Pitt Root find each concept vocabulary word in the future 's finest,. 'S literature with us covers everything from race to religion to the South, Jack negative! See change happening in her life Mamas forgiveness, he comes in spite of his deep aversion to the Rights... Seems extremely stressed after the move, enjoys herself they come to it from this place this. And there was just kind of - there was Another person who I did know. Growing our nails long 'm, like, oh, that 's so not-cute to me x27 ; s.... To Jacqueline and tells her it used to be Jesus, so who Allah! Race, faith, and of every New one we publish presents them comes beg! Start to see change happening in her life mentioning the Southern rain in two poems, she shares what was... Would you describe what your neighborhood was like to grow up as brown girl dreaming poem brooklyn rain American. No, this is not going to happen that reminds them so much of length and pattern are... Was just kind of one way to be poet laureate is to try to spread the love and accessibility! Happily partakes with these racist laws mother and grandmother were Jehovah 's Witnesses was! For the introduction of Bartleby so they dont complain and they just had boxes and boxes stuff. Up, it was just kind of - there was just kind of sense - and it 's a... Lot of hair get updates on New titles we publish and the ability to save highlights and notes would evidence...